2.25 York – Sky Bet Melrose Handicap (Heritage Handicap) (Class 2, £170,000, 1m5f188y, 3yo, Good to Firm)

·

Race Shape / Pace Angles
This is traditionally run at a strong pace with several unexposed stayers in play. The Johnston pair (Pole Star, Novelista) are forward-goers and likely to ensure a proper test, while Fantasy World and Talismans Time also race prominently. Boatswain, Daiquiri Bay, and Many Men tend to be held up, so they’ll be looking for a searching gallop to bring stamina into play.

Draw Angles
York’s extended 1m6f trip generally gives a fair chance from all stalls, though being mid-to-low helps avoid covering too much ground on the first bend. Stalls 1–7 have historically had a marginal edge. Novelista (1), Fantasy World (2), and Talismans Time (3) are well berthed; the likes of Pole Star (11) and Tarriance (12) will need to slot in.


Strongest Contenders

  • Many Men (106 RPR, OR 88, Oisin Murphy) – progressive profile, already a 3-time winner, and shaped like a stayer at Ascot over 2m. Pedigree (dam won at 1m6f+) suggests this trip is ideal. Forgive Haydock blip on tacky ground. A major player with stamina assured. Proven.
  • Pole Star (105 RPR, OR 90, Connor Beasley) – two solid staying efforts at 1m6f+, tough and progressive, Johnston camp has targeted this. Handles varying ground, good draw less of an issue as he stays well. Progressive.
  • Novelista (103 RPR, OR 83, Joe Fanning) – another Johnston improver, twice unlucky not to win, and clearly targeted at this race. Still unexposed and drawn in stall 1 to get a ground-saving trip. Promising.
  • Boatswain (104 RPR, OR 93, Buick) – ran with credit at Ascot in the King George V (strong form) and again at Sandown. Shapes like a grinder who will stay. Buick a notable booking. Promising.

Main Dangers

  • Tarriance (104 RPR, OR 93, Colin Keane) – tough and improving, but wide draw (12) a concern at this trip if forced to do extra early. May need luck slotting in.
  • Daiquiri Bay (100 RPR, OR 93, Rossa Ryan) – consistent, but may lack the finishing kick compared to the classier stayers here. Pedigree suggests further is within reach, though York’s long straight might test his turn of foot.
  • Golden Handshake (103 RPR, OR 88, Tom Marquand) – Haggas runner for The King & Queen, improving steadily, but needs a big step up in class to figure. Interesting.

Interesting Outsiders

  • Sea Of Kings (102 RPR, OR 83, James Doyle) – brother to Sea Of Class, lightly raced, has shaped well in handicaps. Still raw but big potential. Could be the surprise package.
  • Talismans Time (102 RPR, OR 85, Rodriguez) – strong staying pedigree and improving, but yet to prove himself in a big-field heritage handicap.
  • Cape Breton (104 RPR, OR 89, Beckett/Kingscote) – expensive Frankel colt, improving, but this test might find him out unless he’s got a bit more stamina than shown.

Runner Scores (suitability out of 10)

  • Many Men – 9/10 (ideal trip, strong stayer, improving)
  • Pole Star – 8.5/10 (progressive, tough, set for big run)
  • Boatswain – 8/10 (solid form, Buick up, will stay)
  • Novelista – 8/10 (unlucky loser, draw in 1, major player)
  • Tarriance – 7.5/10 (game, but draw a negative)
  • Daiquiri Bay – 7/10 (consistent, but may lack kick)
  • Golden Handshake – 7/10 (progressing, but needs more)
  • Sea Of Kings – 7/10 (potential improver, intriguing profile)
  • Talismans Time – 6.5/10 (unexposed, but needs to prove class)
  • Cape Breton – 6/10 (expensive, but not fully convincing yet)
  • Fantasy World – 6/10 (honest, but perhaps one-paced at this level)
  • Love Talk – 5/10 (Group form misleading, stamina doubts)

Private Tissue (my odds)

  • Many Men 4/1
  • Pole Star 5/1
  • Boatswain 6/1
  • Novelista 7/1
  • Tarriance 9/1
  • Sea Of Kings 10/1
  • Golden Handshake 12/1
  • Daiquiri Bay 12/1
  • Talismans Time 16/1
  • Cape Breton 20/1
  • Fantasy World 25/1
  • Love Talk 33/1

Summary

A proper Melrose, stacked with progressive 3yo stayers. Many Men has the ideal stamina-rich profile and comes here on the upgrade, while Pole Star and Novelista give Johnston a very strong hand. Boatswain looks rock-solid with Buick up, while Sea Of Kings could easily be the late improver lurking on handicap debut.

Smart Play:

  • Win bet: Many Men – progressive stayer with proven form and strong York appeal.
  • Each-way saver: Novelista – still a maiden but has been knocking on the door, and stall 1 is a big plus in this setup.

Leave a comment

Get updates

From art exploration to the latest archeological findings, all here in our weekly newsletter.

Subscribe