This is a proper data-led race with a clear shape, and it should be approached with discipline rather than guesswork.
The Comment Shaper points to a single front runner in Master Richard, but he’s not strong enough to dominate. More importantly, there are three prominent racers applying pressure just behind, which lifts the early tempo without turning it into a total burn-up. The result is a strong overall shape with a moderate collapse risk — exactly the type of setup that suits closers and strong late finishers.
That’s a key point, because plenty in this field finish well, but only a couple marry that with the right ratings profile.
Ratings First – No Deviating
The TimeWise Master ratings are clear:
Flowstate – Rank 1
Philanthropist – Rank 2
Historically, this is where the winner comes from the majority of the time. You need a very good reason to go elsewhere — and there isn’t one here.
The Case for Flowstate
Flowstate is the standout because everything aligns:
Top-rated
Consistent hold-up performer
Proven strong finisher (⭐⭐⭐)
Stable run style with high confidence
In a race where the pace is likely to be honest and the leaders vulnerable late, he should get the race run exactly to suit. He doesn’t need things to fall perfectly — just a fair gallop and a clear run.
That’s as solid a profile as you’ll get in this grade.
The Only Danger – Philanthropist
Philanthropist is the obvious alternative:
Also a strong finisher
Slightly more tactical in running style
Sits second on ratings
However, there are niggles:
149-day absence
Less consistent behaviour pattern
If fully wound up, he’s the one who can capitalise late, but you’re taking fitness on trust.
The Rest
Beale Street and Cargin Bhui both have strong finishing profiles, but neither has the ratings to justify overturning the top two. In this type of race, that usually matters.
The front-end runners, particularly Master Richard, look vulnerable given their tendency to weaken under pressure.
Final Word
This isn’t a race to overcomplicate. The shape suits closers, and the ratings point firmly at one horse.
Flowstate is the percentage call.
Self-Critique
The main risk is over-reliance on race shape. If the pace underperforms or turns tactical, Flowstate could be left with too much to do. There’s also the usual danger with hold-up horses in a straight 7f — traffic and timing.
Philanthropist’s absence adds uncertainty too — if he’s fully fit, he could easily match or exceed the selection.
Selection: Flowstate (IRE)
Confidence: Strong
8.00 Newcastle – Don’t Settle For Less Handicap🏇⤵️👇
Get updates
From art exploration to the latest archeological findings, all here in our weekly newsletter.
Subscribe
Leave a comment