2.35 Newbury – John Porter Stakes (Group 3)

This revolves around a very familiar pattern: top of the HRB TimeWise stack dominates, and this race looks no different on paper.

🧠 Race Shape

Comment Shaper is clear — no obvious front runner, weak pace setup. That matters.

Likely steady gallop

Prominent racers could control things

Hold-up horses risk being poorly positioned


That immediately puts pressure on the likes of Al Aasy (habitual hold-up) despite his class.


—

🏇 HRB Ratings Angle (Primary Lens)

1st Convergent (435.7) – clear top rank

2nd Pride Of Arras (NR) – now out, removes the only real statistical danger

Big drop to the rest


This is key: with Rank 2 out, the historical edge of the top two collapses onto the #1 alone.


—

🧩 Runner-by-Runner (Focused)

Convergent (Rank 1)

Progressive 4yo with proper Group form:

G3 win → G2 win → forgive G1 flop on soft

Returns on ideal ground

Tactical versatility (important in this pace setup)


Only concern: giving weight away, but he’s the one still improving.


—

Al Aasy

Class act, former winner of this race, and strong fresh.

But:

Hold-up style + no pace = problem

At 9yo, not getting any quicker tactically

Comment Shaper flags him as needing things to collapse — unlikely here


He’ll come late… but possibly too late.


—

Lion’s Pride

Very interesting in context:

Timeform specifically flags pace bias in his favour

Ryan Moore booked

Can sit closer than Al Aasy


However:

Inconsistent profile

Not obviously well treated on ratings vs Convergent


More of a solid place player than a win bet.


—

Phantom Flight

In form and arrives fit:

Recent Group 3 win

Prominent style suits race shape


But:

Likely flattered slightly by weaker race

Needs another step forward at 7yo — unlikely



—

Tenability (Rank 3 – caution)

Fits the “include only with strong support” rule:

Progressive profile

Strong finisher

First-time tongue tie


But:

Ratings well short

Needs a career-best leap


Not quite enough to break the top-tier bias.


—

Bellum Justum

Feels like a prep run:

Yard targets later races

First run after gelding

Poor reappearance record


Easy pass.


—

🔍 Self-Critique

The obvious concern is race tempo. A very steady pace can produce messy outcomes, and that can blunt the edge of the best horse if positioning goes wrong.

However:

Convergent is tactically adaptable

Main danger (Pride Of Arras) is out

Key rival (Al Aasy) is pace-dependent in the wrong way


So while the setup introduces minor uncertainty, it does not undermine the core ratings edge.


—

🧾 Verdict

Everything funnels back to one horse:

Top HRB rank

Improving profile

Ground in his favour

Main statistical rival withdrawn

Tactically suited to likely race shape


✅ Selection: CONVERGENT


—

💪 Strength of Selection: STRONG

With Rank 2 out and conditions aligning, this is exactly the kind of setup where the HRB top-rated should be trusted rather than opposed.