1m4f6y, Good to Soft (with rain around), 14 runners

The Derby is unlike any other British Flat race. Epsom’s cambers, downhill run, turning nature and demanding final climb place a premium on balance, stamina and temperament. This year’s ground description of good to soft introduces an extra stamina test.

Race Shape, Pace & Draw

Pace

There is no obvious guaranteed tearaway, but several who have raced prominently:

Action is the most likely pace angle and made the running in the Dante.

Ancient Egypt has raced handily.

Bay Of Brilliance has made all before.

Christmas Day generally races prominently.


The likely scenario is an honest rather than extreme gallop, which should ensure the race becomes a proper test of stamina.

Draw

Over 1m4f at Epsom, draw is less significant than in sprint races because there is a long run before the first major bend. However:

Low to middle draws can secure position more easily.

Wide draws require tactical judgement and risk covering extra ground.


Notable stalls:

Positive

Maltese Cross (1)

Balzac (2)

Item (3)

Poker (4)


Potentially tricky

Benvenuto Cellini (12)

James J Braddock (13)

Rebel Rocker (14)


The pace-and-draw interaction slightly favours those drawn low-middle who can obtain a handy position without expending energy.


—

Assessing the Race Correctly

For this Derby, the most important factors are:

1. Stamina suitability


2. Track suitability (Epsom balance and handling)


3. Class/form achieved


4. Ground suitability


5. Temperament


6. Pace positioning



Less important than usual:

Draw

Pure speed ratings


This is a race where proven stamina and handling potential deserve extra weighting.


—

Runner-by-Runner Ratings

1. Benvenuto Cellini (p)

9.5/10

Chester Vase winner.

Proven 1m4f stamina.

Chester form often translates well to Epsom because both tracks demand balance.

Best combination of stamina and class.

Slight concern if the ground becomes notably softer.


The most proven Derby profile in the field.


—

2. Item (P)

9.0/10

Unbeaten.

Dante winner.

Highest recent RPR in the field (130).

Still looked green and keen at York.


The main question is whether he fully stays a Derby 1m4f under testing conditions. Huge talent but less proven than Benvenuto Cellini at the trip.


—

3. Pierre Bonnard (p)

8.8/10

Group 1 winner at two.

Stays 1m2f strongly.

Pedigree strongly suggests improvement at 1m4f.

Better latest effort at Leopardstown.


Looks to be peaking at the right time.


—

4. James J Braddock (p)

8.6/10

Strong-finishing Leopardstown Derby Trial winner.

Shaped as though 1m4f is exactly what he wants.

Ground should suit.

Draw 13 not ideal.


Major each-way contender.


—

5. Maltese Cross (p)

8.4/10

Lingfield Derby Trial winner.

Lingfield form is traditionally relevant to Epsom.

Thorough stayer.

Draw 1 useful.


Looks a solid Derby type and remains progressive.


—

6. Bay Of Brilliance (p)

7.9/10

Chased Maltese Cross home at Lingfield.

Could improve from seasonal debut.

Stamina likely.


Needs another step forward but remains interesting.


—

7. Christmas Day (p)

7.8/10

Ballysax winner.

Stayed on steadily in Dante.

Looks one-paced rather than lacking stamina.


May sneak into the places if others fail to stay.


—

8. Action

7.5/10

Strong juvenile form.

Dante second.

Possible pace angle.

Cheekpieces tried.


Needs improvement but could prove hard to pass for a long way.


—

9. Ancient Egypt (p)

7.4/10

Listed winner.

Frankel colt.

Stamina not yet fully tested.


Interesting outsider from a respected stable.


—

10. Rebel Rocker (P)

5.5/10

Eyecatching Epsom trial run.

Strong stayer.

Lacks class evidence.


Needs a huge leap.


—

11. Balzac (p)

5.0/10

Stays well.

Improving.


But trial form leaves him with plenty to find.


—

12. Alderman (P)

4.5/10

Scopey and unexposed.

Promising staying pedigree.


Looks a Derby horse for next season rather than today.


—

13. Poker

3.5/10

Expensive purchase.

Hasn’t shown Derby-winning ability.


Hard to support on form.


—

14. A Taste Of Glory

2.5/10

Handicap winner.

Well held in Derby trial.


Faces an enormous task.


—

Strongest Contenders

Benvenuto Cellini (p)

Most complete profile. Proven stamina, proven Group form and Chester Vase route is historically strong.

Item (P)

Highest ceiling in the race. Dante winner and unbeaten. If he settles and stays, he could simply be the best horse.

Pierre Bonnard (p)

Group 1 juvenile who looks poised to improve significantly over this trip.


—

Main Dangers

James J Braddock (p)

Maltese Cross (p)

Christmas Day (p)



—

Interesting Outsiders

Ancient Egypt (p)

Listed winner who may improve again over 1m4f.

Bay Of Brilliance (p)

Lingfield runner-up who could step forward from first run of the season.


—

Hold-Up Risks

The following could require luck in running:

James J Braddock

Rebel Rocker

Alderman


Coming from behind in a Derby field can be difficult if the pace steadies.


—

Trainer Notes

Aidan O’Brien

Dominates modern Derby history and fields:

Benvenuto Cellini

Pierre Bonnard

Christmas Day

Action


When O’Brien has multiple runners, the market does not always identify the winning one.


—

Private Tissue

Horse Tissue

Benvenuto Cellini 26%
Item 22%
Pierre Bonnard 15%
James J Braddock 11%
Maltese Cross 9%
Christmas Day 5%
Bay Of Brilliance 4%
Action 4%
Ancient Egypt 2%
Others combined 2%



—

Summary

This looks a particularly strong Derby. Item brings the best recent performance through the Dante, but Benvenuto Cellini owns the most complete Derby profile: proven stamina, Chester Vase credentials and a style that suggests Epsom should suit.

Pierre Bonnard remains the dark horse among the leading contenders and may yet fulfil the immense promise he showed at two.

For each-way purposes, James J Braddock and Maltese Cross appeal most among those outside the front rank.

ChatGPT Smart Plays

Win Bet

Benvenuto Cellini (9.5/10, p)
The most proven combination of stamina, class and Derby suitability.

Saver / Each-Way

James J Braddock (8.6/10, p)
Strong-finishing Leopardstown Trial winner who shapes like a thorough 1m4f horse and should be staying on when others have cried enough.

Predicted 1-2-3

1. Benvenuto Cellini


2. Item


3. Pierre Bonnard


4. James J Braddock


5. Maltese Cross